Blockstream’s Solar Bitcoin Project seems Uneconomic

  • Blockstream and Block (formerly Square) and Tesla have partnered to build a Bitcoin mining facility powered solely by solar plus batteries.
  • Bitcoin miners compete based on their energy costs, and new mining projects target energy costs of less than $0.03/kWh.
  • Based on 12 MWh of batteries, 3.8 MW of solar and 30 PH/s of ASICs, the Blockstream project will have energy costs of at least $0.15/kWh.
  • Even cutting battery costs in five, energy would cost about $0.1/kWh
  1. The computers (ASICs) used for mining don’t like thermal cycling. This forces high levels of energy storage in order to provide a near continuous power supply.
  2. Even without thermal cycling (in which case energy storage could be avoided), the high intermittency of solar and wind results in high downtime for the ASICs, which significantly reduces the payback period on capital deployed.
  1. The project appears sized to avoid thermal cycling of the ASICs. Based on information on the solar panels and the batteries, it seems it will be possible to run the ASICs with about 70%+ uptime. This is a lot higher than the 20–30% uptime there would be without energy storage. This makes sense given ASICs are known not to like thermal cycling.
  2. Blockstream project energy costs are expensive. Bitcoin mining is all about having cheap energy. Miners with the cheapest energy can stay turned on for the longest when revenue falls (either due to falling Bitcoin price or rising network hashrate). From conversations with the top Bitcoin mining pools, I learned that new projects seek out energy cheaper than $0.03/kWh. By contrast, the — optimistically calculated — cost of power from this Blockstream project is $0.15/kWh.

--

--

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Pinotio

Pinotio

Your Guide Through Decentralised Finance (Defi). Subscribe at Pinotio.com for the full experience.